Yes, an automatic pool cover can be used as an alternative to a winter cover. However, its durability and performance primarily depend on the winter weather conditions. This guide outlines the key similarities and differences between the automatic and winter pool covers, and discovers which cover is better in different weather and lifestyle conditions.
What is an Automatic Pool Cover?
An Automatic Pool Safety Cover is a pool cover typically made from vinyl. With tracks installed around the pool decking, this retractable cover is motorized with one click of a button. This simple, motorized system allows for easy, practical daily use to protect the pool.
Automatic Pool Covers are highly effective at protecting against:
- Debris and leaves
- Algae growth
- Heat loss
- Sunlight depleting Chlorine
Instead of spending hours cleaning, continue to enjoy the relaxation of your dip in the water with the convenience of the automatic covers. The heat retention automatic pool covers provide is a cost-effective, energy-efficient method as you can avoid running the pool heater every time you want to swim.
Often these covers have the ability to be locked, adding an additional safety measure to your home. Paired alongside a gated fence, these safety measures protect small kids and pets from accidental drownings.
What is a Winter Pool Cover?
Pool maintenance continues long after the swim season ends. A Winter Pool Cover is a pool cover typically made from heavy-duty, woven mesh or solid vinyl.
The solid material requires an electric pump to be installed as well to drain the rainwater or melted snow that accumulates on the cover’s surface. The mesh material allows water to drain through, eliminating the need for an additional drainage system. However, it may allow sunlight to pass through, increasing the risk of algae growth or chlorine depletion.
Winter Pool Covers are specifically built for:
- Bearing heavy snow and ice loads
- Withstanding freezing, windy temperatures
- Long-term, seasonal protection of the pool
Winter covers require manual installation before the winter season begins. Installing winter pool covers often completed with a set of anchors and springs. Ensure your pool deck is cleared and in strong condition to secure. Additionally, remove any obstructions such as pool ladders and debris from the pool water.
Key Differences: Which is Better an Automatic or Winter Pool Cover?
1. When to Use Automatic Pool Cover vs Winter?
Automatic pool covers are designed to be used both during pool season and during mild off seasons, while winter pool covers are designed specifically for the pool off-season. Automatic pool covers are meant to be opened and closed frequently during use; however, winter pool covers are dedicated to seasonal, long-term protection.
Automatic pool covers often experience increased wear under the weight load of heavy, frequent snowfall, and their mechanisms may falter under freezing conditions. It is not encouraged to use an automatic cover as a replacement for winter covers in those weather conditions.
2. Durability Comparison
Automatic Pool Covers are built for daily use during pool season. They typically last between 5-10 years. To maximize their lifespan, get annual servicing and replace materials, like fabric and rope, frequently.
Winter Pool Covers are specifically meant for the heavy load of snowfall, harsh winds, and freezing temperatures. The heavy-duty vinyl and mesh covers typically last for 7-15 years with proper installation and maintenance.
3. Price Comparison
Automatic Pool Safety Covers are expensive to buy and install, ranging from $12,000-20,000. The price increases with more advanced safety measures and aesthetics. Many pool owners remark that the features and convenience provided in an automatic pool cover makes the price worth it.
On the other hand, Winter Pool Safety Covers are a more affordable pool protection method. To buy and install with additional equipment, they range from $1,000-4,000. Standard tarps are even less expensive, but do not guarantee the same safety and durability measures as mesh or vinyl covers.
When is an Automatic Sufficient Enough to Replace a Winter Cover?
Pool owners can answer this question by determining their weather and lifestyle conditions.
Automatic pool covers would add an additional level of convenience if sufficient to protect the pool during the off-season. This opportunity may be the case if you live in an area with mild winter weathers, experiencing:
- Little to no snowfalls
- Reduced winds
- Temperatures primarily above freezing
- Lack of ice accumulation
- Abundant sunshine
If you decide to use an automatic pool cover for annual pool protection, ensure water levels are maintained and balanced, and install a drainage pump to maintain the durability of the cover during the off-season.
Which Pool Cover is Right for Your Backyard?
Choose an Automatic Pool Cover If You:
- Live in area of mild winters
- Prioritize daily convenience and safety
- Want an effortless pool opening and closing operation
Choose a Winter Pool Cover If You:
- Live in area of harsh winters weathers, such as NY or CT
- Want minimal maintenance and pool clean-up in the springtime
- Seek an affordable, heavy-duty pool cover
For further understanding, read a previous Shoreline Pools’ blog on the importance of covering your pool!
Seek a Professional Opinion with Shoreline Pools
If you live in the Connecticut or New York area, Shoreline Pools strongly recommends using a winter cover during the pool off-season for maximum protection due to harsh winter storms and temperatures. And during swimming season use an automatic pool cover for convenient safety and clean up measures.
Shoreline Pools additionally specializes in inground pool cover repairs for these common failures. Whether it’s repair, installation, or advice you seek, Shoreline Pools is ready to assist your special pool needs.
Call 203-357-1544 and schedule a service appointment today!
