Everyone loves to say, “Just repair it, it’s more affordable!” But when safety and long-term costs are on the line, that shortcut might not be the bargain you think it is.
A lot of people swear by “affordable fixes” for pool covers, but not all of these hacks prove to be smart investments. Sometimes, repairing instead of replacing something can drain money faster than a slow, unnoticeable leak. Replacement initially sounds pricey, but in most cases, it’s a safer, cleaner, and smarter choice. Read this guide to learn when repairing your pool cover can work, when replacement can save money long-term, and how to avoid spending unnecessary money.
Why Pool Covers Matter
A pool cover is a necessary piece of equipment, not only for added safety but also to save costs in the long run. Pool covers are anchored to your pool deck and are designed to hold a minimum of 485lbs, per safety standards, to prevent accidental entry into the pool.
They can also help prevent heat loss, evaporation, and debris like branches and leaves from falling into the pool, which can become costly expenses over time.
Signs Your Pool Cover is Still Repairable
Minor Tears and Surface Wear
Small tears can often be patched with DIY kits. The type of kit you use depends on whether your pool cover is made of vinyl or mesh materials. A vinyl cover is repaired using a patch and adhesive whereas mesh covers are repaired by stitching a patch onto the damaged area.
Loose or Broken Springs
Replacing the springs that are attached to your pool cover is a fairly simple task. These can be purchased at most hardware and pool supply stores. Make sure to purchase the correct size of springs for your cover. These typically come with instructions, but if you need further assistance, there are many tutorials available online and professional service options.
Strap Stretch and Adjustments
While adjusting the straps of your pool cover may be a time-consuming task, it is possible to do it on your own:
- Attach the strap springs loosely to the anchors around your pool.
- Go around the perimeter of the pool and slightly tighten each strap.
- Repeat until there is an even overlap around the edge of the pool.
When Should I Replace My Pool Cover?
Weakened or Thinning Fabric
While pool covers are designed to last, they still need to be replaced after a certain period of time. As time goes on, different factors such as UV penetration and natural weather can impact the durability of your pool cover. This can cause overall weakening or the fabric to thin in certain areas. Either way, these are both signs that your cover is no longer safe to use and needs to be replaced.
Widespread Damage and Need for Multiple Repairs
If a pool cover is damaged in multiple areas, it is time to consider replacing it instead of attempting to repair it. Extensive damage to your pool cover can compromise the structural integrity, making it no longer safe to use. Attempting to repair a cover like this will likely exceed the cost of replacing it in the long run due to the need for continuous and higher maintenance.
Outgrown Size or Poor Fit
Your pool cover should always be the proper fit for your specific pool. However, covers made of certain materials can shrink over time due to various factors such as exposure to heat or water pressure. As a pool cover ages, it will begin to lose its elasticity and become prone to sagging, making it no longer suitable to hold weight. Size issues cannot be repaired; therefore, incorrectly sized pool covers must be replaced to ensure proper safety.
Pros and Cons of Pool Cover Repair vs. Replacement:
Repairing a Pool Cover
Pros:
- Cheaper than replacement
- Minor repairs are usually quick
- The lifespan of your cover can be extended
Cons:
- Repairs may not last for long which can become costly in the long run
- Complex repairs can be difficult and expensive
- Visible patches may not be aesthetically appealing
Replacing a Pool Cover
Pros:
- Enhanced safety and peace of mind
- New pool covers are higher quality and more durable
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost compared to repairing
- Proper installation can be time consuming
Pool Cover Maintenance Tips
Off-Season Storage
Properly storing your pool cover can also help it stay in good condition. Take these steps to ensure you are storing your pool cover correctly:
- Thoroughly remove any dirt and debris from the cover’s surface.
- Dry the cover off completely.
- Place the cover into a pool cover bag and store it in a dry place.
Regular Inspections
Pool covers should be inspected at least once a season to properly identify signs of potential damage and repair issues before they worsen.
Professional Help When Needed
When it comes to pool safety, don’t risk it. If you’re unsure about whether repairing or replacement is the better option for your pool cover, don’t worry. The team at Shoreline Pools can help guide you with our expert recommendations. Call us at (203) 357-1544 today and let our specialists help you make the best decision for your pool’s long-term safety and performance.
